Tonkin Subaru

Nima Behboodi runs one store in The Dalles, Oregon. The auction that used to stock his used lot stopped producing, and a town of 15,000 does not throw off enough trades to cover the gap. He bought more than 100 cars off the street in six months, and about ten of the people he bought from turned around and bought a vehicle from him.

Type:
Franchise
Brand:
Subaru Corporation
Problem:
High Auction Costs
Poor Vehicle Quality
Staffing/Manpower
Solution:
Dedicated Buyers
Listing Aggregation
Follow-Up System
Get a Demo
VETTX CEO Conner Windust with Nima Behboodi outside Tonkin of the Gorge Subaru in The Dalles, Oregon

Problem

The auction stopped producing. Lanes that once ran two and three thousand cars are down to a thousand, half of them rental units. Fees that were around $350 when Nima started have climbed past $1,100, and arbitration windows have narrowed from a week to three to five days. A town of 15,000 people does not throw off enough trades to cover that gap.

Strategy

He worked private party listings himself for the first 30 days to find out whether the channel was real. Once it proved out, he built a permanent seat around it: one filtered list of private sellers worked every morning, instead of one auction morning a week.

Results

More than 100 cars off the street in six months. Cars reach the front line in days instead of waiting on parts, inventory holds steady year round without panic buying, and about ten of the private sellers he bought from came back and bought a vehicle from him.

Key Metrics

100+

Cars bought off the street in 6 months

15,000

People in his town

A Town of 15,000 People

Tonkin of the Gorge is a single store in The Dalles, Oregon. Nima Behboodi has run it for nine years, long enough to know exactly what sells in his market and what does not.

The auction that used to stock his used lot stopped producing. Lanes that once ran two and three thousand cars are down to a thousand, half of them rental units. Fees that were around $350 when he started have climbed past $1,100. Arbitration windows that used to run a week now run three to five days. None of it happened all at once. The economics that made the lane work for twenty years quietly stopped working.

The obvious fix is to source more trades. That option is not available to him. A town of 15,000 people does not generate enough trade-ins to stock a used lot, which means he either pulls cars from outside his own market or he goes without.

About half of all used vehicles in America change hands between private parties rather than through a dealership. Those cars sit in driveways in small markets too. They just never show up in a lane.

He Ran the First 30 Days Himself

Nima did not need convincing that private party worked. He had been doing it by hand on the classifieds and marketplace apps for years, and he already knew the cars were out there. What he did not have was a way to reach them at volume without burning his week.

When he signed, he did not hand it to anyone else. He cleared three or four days and worked the listings personally, every free moment, using a pre-loaded message he had written years before. He would spend the day messaging sellers and get home to find the replies stacked up.

"I got 13 responses on my cell phone." - Nima Behboodi

Thirty-two cars came in that first month. Every one of them sold.

Who Belongs in the Seat

The handoff is the part he gets asked about most. His answer is that the seat needs somebody who can already value a car.

"You either need to teach them that knowledge, or you got to plug somebody in that actually knows it." - Nima Behboodi

His recommendation to every store that signs up is the used car manager. Not the GM, not a new hire. The used car manager is already doing this exact job every week, just at an auction instead of at a desk.

"They're spending most of their days going through the lane anyway. Why would you not just make the lane right on your computer every day?" - Nima Behboodi

VETTX put the power back in my hand and made every day a lane day.

Nima Behboodi, General Manager, Tonkin of the Gorge

Outbound Instead of Inbound

Nima had already tried the inbound tools. Instant cash offer, trade appraisal widgets, the category generally. His read on all of them is the same. They are marketing, and marketing leaves you waiting.

"Nothing's worse than waiting for someone to come to you versus you being able to go get it and bring it in." - Nima Behboodi

He puts the difference in conversion terms. Most of the people who click an instant cash offer are just curious what their car is worth. Everyone on a private party listing has already decided to sell.

"Do you know how much easier it is to have a conversation with somebody trying to sell something, than you trying to sell them something?" - Nima Behboodi

The Lot Stopped Swinging

The change he describes is less about software than about the calendar. The auction gave him one buying day a week, so every shortage had to be solved on that one morning, against everyone else who needed cars that day. He would build up to thirty-three used units, sell ten or twelve in a single week, drop to twenty-one, and then go buy badly to refill the concrete.

"It took the panic buying away from me." - Nima Behboodi

A list that is open every day removes the deadline. The cars changed too. People maintain their own vehicles, so a street car needs an oil change and a cabin filter, not a part on order. Those cars reach the front line in days rather than sitting two weeks waiting on something to arrive.

The Follow-Up Is the Job

His one piece of tactical advice is unglamorous. He treats the platform like a CRM. New listings he likes move to an In the Works list, and every few days he works that list from the bottom back up to the top, clearing out whatever sold or got pulled.

The bottom of the list is where the cars come from. A car he loses at auction is gone. A private seller who turned down his number in week one is usually still listed in week four, and by then the price has come to him.

"I can't tell you how many times we bought a car three or four weeks after we reached out to them, for the price that we wanted. They just needed to get there on their own." - Nima Behboodi

He Will Pay Up for the Right Car

The mistake he sees other dealers make is pricing a street car like an auction car. Nima will go over book for something he knows sells in his town. The first car he bought this way was a 2014 Forester with 79,000 miles that booked around $6,800. He paid just over eight thousand for it, priced it at eleven, and sold it in three days.

His reasoning is the oldest line in the business. You do not make money selling a car, you make money when you buy it. A clean, one-owner car out of a driveway is worth more to him than the book says it is.

The Part Nobody Expects

About ten of the private sellers Nima bought cars from ended up buying a vehicle from him, most of them from outside his market.

One was a woman in Bend whose family was growing. He bought her 2018 Forester, and she mentioned they were shopping for an Ascent and already working with their local dealer. He had three on the ground, one in the color and trim she wanted. She drove down and bought it from him instead. Another was a man with a large roofing company who sold him a 2020 F-150. They hit it off. Three days later he drove his sister out to the store, and she bought a new car.

"Not only am I acquiring cars, I'm earning customers as well." - Nima Behboodi

What Tonkin of the Gorge Built

  • More than 100 cars bought off the street in six months
  • 32 in the first full month, every one of them sold
  • One auction morning a week replaced by a buying list that is open every day
  • Cars on the front line in days instead of two weeks waiting on a part
  • Inventory held steady year round, without panic buying to fill the lot
  • About ten vehicles sold back to private sellers he bought cars from

What He Tells Other Dealers

Nima is blunt about who this works for. It rewards attention, and it punishes anyone expecting it to run itself.

"Anybody that doesn't succeed on this platform, it's because they just don't give it the respect and the time that it needs and deserves." - Nima Behboodi

His larger point is that dealers have always adapted. Laserdisc to VHS, VHS to DVD, DVD to streaming. He puts private party acquisition in the same category.

"I just see that as the used car evolution that's coming." - Nima Behboodi